Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Rust vs C++: which one should you choose for your project?

Alexandra Mendes

February 05, 2024

Min Read
Rust vs C++: which one should you choose for your project?

What is Rust?

Rust is a systems programming language that tries to deliver the performance of C and C++ while also incorporating memory and thread safety. Mozilla designed it and launched it in 2010, with the first stable release in 2015.

Rust also supports functional and procedural programming methods and offers an easy-to-learn and grasp syntax. Rust's package manager, Cargo, provides a centralised mechanism for managing dependencies and constructing projects.

Since then, Rust has become prominent in the programming world, particularly in systems programming, web development, networking, and cloud computing.

The Benefits of Rust

  • Memory safety guarantees prevent common mistakes like null pointer dereferences and buffer overflows
  • The ownership concept provides proper memory management
  • The borrowing and lifetimes mechanism ensures thread safety and prevents data races
  • High-performance code production is frequently on par with C++ or faster in some cases
  • The modern and expressive syntax allows for easier code building and maintenance.

Disadvantages of Rust

  • Relatively young language with a smaller ecosystem than established languages like C++ or Java
  • Locating specific libraries and tools can be challenging
  • The syntax may be complex for developers from other languages
  • Emphasis on performance can lead to more complex code than in different languages, making it more difficult to read and understand.
blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo
blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo

What is C++?

C++ is a popular high-performance programming language, particularly in game creation, systems programming, and scientific computing. It’s a C programming language extension with object-oriented programming, generic programming, and exception management capabilities. Bjarne Stroustrup designed it in the 1980s as a general-purpose computer language.

The Benefits of C++

  • High-performance language suitable for applications like game engines and scientific simulations
  • Supports direct memory manipulation and system resource access
  • Portability allows code to run on multiple operating systems and hardware architectures
  • A vast and active community providing comprehensive libraries and tools
  • Versatile language supporting several programming paradigms for multiple applications.

Disadvantages of C++

  • Broad library and toolset can be overwhelming for some developers
  • The complexity of the language can be intimidating for newcomers
  • Memory management can be error-prone, leading to difficulties like memory leaks and dangling pointers
  • It lacks built-in concurrency capabilities, making it more difficult to develop concurrent programs.

4 things to remember when choosing a tech stack for your web development project

Performance

Performance is an important consideration when selecting a programming language. Rust and C++ are famed for their speed, but how do they compare?

Comparing Rust vs C++ performance

In general, the performance of Rust and C++ is equivalent. Both languages are compiled and offer direct memory access and low-level control over system resources. Rust's ownership model and borrowing system enable memory and thread safety without requiring a garbage collector, resulting in quicker and more predictable performance. C++'s more extensive library support can sometimes produce more efficient code than Rust.

Benchmarking the two technologies

Several benchmarks have compared the performance of Rust vs C++ in various use situations. The Computer Language Benchmarks Game is a prominent benchmark that analyses the performance of computer languages in diverse tasks such as numerical algorithms, file I/O, and string manipulation.

In most instances, C++ surpasses Rust in this benchmark. On the other hand, Rust outperforms C++ in some tests, such as binary trees, where Rust is more than twice as fast as C++.

It's important to note that benchmark results can vary based on the use case, hardware, and compiler utilised. To evaluate which language suits their purposes, developers should consider their performance requirements and benchmark their code in their specific use case.

blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo

Memory Management

Memory management is critical in programming languages because it impacts performance, safety, and dependability. Memory management algorithms in Rust and C++ differ, affecting their applicability for different applications.

Rust memory management

Rust employs a novel method of memory management known as ownership and borrowing. This technique guarantees memory safety at compile time, eliminating the requirement for a garbage collector at runtime.

The ownership mechanism assures that at any given time, only one variable has to write access to a portion of memory, eliminating data races and memory corruption. The borrowing mechanism permits multiple read-only references to the same memory piece, improving memory efficiency.

C++ memory management

Manual memory management is used in C++, giving developers low-level control over memory allocation and deallocation. This method is flexible and can result in efficient code. Manual memory management, on the other hand, can result in issues such as memory leaks, dangling pointers, and buffer overflows. This can be difficult to debug and jeopardise security.

Comparing memory management in Rust and C++

Although Rust and C++ support direct memory access, Rust's ownership and borrowing scheme ensures memory safety without losing efficiency. Manual memory management in C++ can result in efficient code but requires careful management to avoid problems. Rust's memory management can also make concurrent programmes easier to write because it ensures thread safety without using locks or mutexes.

Overall, Rust's memory management provides a unique method that balances efficiency, safety, and reliability, making it an appealing alternative for developers searching for a memory-intensive language. However, manual memory management in C++ can still be a viable choice for some applications, particularly those requiring fine-grained control over memory allocation.

blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo

The Learning Curve and Syntax

The syntax and learning curve are key elements when selecting a programming language. Developers must examine how easy a language is to learn and how comfortable they are working with its syntax.

Rust syntax

The syntax of Rust is similar to that of C++ and other C-like languages, with curly braces denoting code blocks and semicolons denoting statement ends. Rust, on the other hand, has various unique characteristics, such as its ownership and borrowing system, which can take some time to grasp completely.

C++ syntax

The syntax of C++ is similar to that of C, with curly braces denoting blocks of code and semicolons denoting the end of statements. C++, on the other hand, contains some unique features, such as templates and operator overloading, which can take some time to master completely.

Comparing syntax

Overall, each language has its own set of features and peculiarities that developers must understand. While Rust and C++ have comparative syntax, Rust's ownership and borrowing structure might be challenging to grasp. But templates and operator overloading in C++ can also be difficult to get.

Here's an example code snippet that showcases some of the key differences between Rust and C++:

Rust code:


C++ code:


This code shows the main differences between the languages:

  • Type annotations: Rust requires variables to be explicitly annotated with their type, while C++ employs type inference based on their initializers.
  • Memory safety: Rust's ownership model prevents data races and null pointer dereferencing at compilation time, while C++'s manual memory management can cause dangling pointers and buffer overflows.
  • Error handling: Rust utilises Result types and match, while C++ uses exceptions and try-catch blocks.
  • Syntax: Pattern matching and closures make Rust's syntax more compact and expressive than C++.

Rust's learning curve

Because of its ownership and borrowing system, Rust has a steep learning curve. Developers must understand the ownership concept and borrowing system to design safe and efficient code in Rust. Rust, on the other hand, can be a powerful and efficient language once developers grasp these notions.

C++ learning curve

Because of its low-level control over system resources and manual memory management, C++ also has a steep learning curve. To design efficient and safe C++ code, developers must grasp pointers, memory allocation, and deallocation.

Comparing learning curves

The learning curves for Rust and C++ are both steep but for different reasons. Rust's ownership and borrowing mechanism can be difficult to grasp, whereas C++'s low-level control over system resources can be overpowering. However, once developers become acquainted with the languages, they can be robust and efficient development tools. When deciding between Rust and C++, developers should evaluate their demands and experience.

Ease of Development and Debugging

When deciding between Rust and C++, developers should evaluate their development and debugging experiences. The simplicity of development and debugging can substantially impact the development process's productivity and efficiency.

Rust development experience

Rust features a powerful toolchain, which includes a package manager (Cargo) and a build system, making it simple to manage dependencies and build projects. Rust also significantly emphasises error management and provides developers with useful error messages. The Rust community is vibrant and supportive, offering many resources from which developers can learn and seek assistance.

C++ development experience

C++ also has a strong toolchain, which includes several popular IDEs, compilers, and building systems. However, managing dependencies can be more complex than in Rust. The language's low-level control over system resources might complicate development.

Rust debugging experience

Rust features a unique feature called "borrow checker," which may detect many common memory-related issues at build time, making bug-free programmes easier to develop. Rust also includes many debugging tools, such as the Rust debugger (rust-gdb) and the Rust Language Server, to assist developers in debugging their code.

C++ debugging experience

Debugging tools for C++ include the GNU Debugger (GDB) and the Visual Studio Debugger. However, because memory-related issues can be harder to spot in C++, debugging can be more complex than in Rust.

Comparing development and debugging experiences

Rust and C++ have powerful toolchains and debugging tools. However, Rust's emphasis on error handling and borrow checking might make writing bug-free code easier. Rust's package manager and build system can make dependency management easier than C++. C++, on the other hand, has a larger developer community, and many popular libraries and frameworks are developed in C++, making accessing resources and problem solutions easier. Finally, the choice between Rust and C++ will be determined by the project's requirements and the developers' expertise and preferences.

blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo
blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo

Community and Support

When selecting a programming language, it is critical to consider community and support. The availability of resources, the size of the developer community, and the degree of support can all substantially impact the speed and efficiency of the development process.

Overview of the Rust community and support

Rust has a fast-developing development community that comprises both industry experts and enthusiasts. The Rust community is noted for its friendliness, support, and activity. The official documentation for Rust is substantial and well-written. There are various online forums and chat rooms where developers can seek assistance and discuss their experiences. Third-party libraries and frameworks can also be easily found and used thanks to Rust's package manager (Cargo).

Overview of the C++ community and support

C++ has been around for decades and has a thriving developer community. C++ has many widely used and supported libraries and frameworks, such as Boost and Qt. There are multiple C++-specific online forums, discussion boards, and numerous books and online resources for developers to learn from.

blue arrow to the left
Imaginary Cloud logo

Use Cases

The final decision between Rust and C++ will be determined by the project's specific requirements and the developers' preferences. Both languages have advantages and disadvantages, and each shines in specific use scenarios.

Rust applications

Rust is a programming language for systems that provides memory safety, concurrency, and speed. Because of Rust's memory safety features, it's a popular choice for designing safety-critical systems like autonomous vehicles, medical equipment, and aerospace applications. It's a good choice for creating high-performance, dependable programmes like operating systems, web servers, and browser engines.

Rust's speed and memory efficiency make it ideal for creating high-performance applications like game engines and machine learning algorithms. Rocket, Rust's web framework, is also gaining popularity among developers for developing web apps.

Companies that use Rust: Figma, Discord, and Coursera.

C++ applications

C++ is a sophisticated and adaptable programming language used in various applications, from system software to game creation. C++ is well-known for its excellent performance. It is widely used in applications requiring rapid execution, such as real-time systems, 3D graphics, and scientific computing.

C++ is a popular programming language for creating operating systems, compilers, and database systems. C++'s object-oriented programming capabilities make it ideal for creating complex software applications like enterprise and finance systems.

Companies that use C++: Adobe, Microsoft, and Apple.

Alexandra Mendes
Alexandra Mendes

Content writer with a big curiosity about the impact of technology on society. Always surrounded by books and music.

Read more posts by this author

People who read this post, also found these interesting:

arrow left
arrow to the right
Dropdown caret icon